EXPERTS
REVIEW MOST RECENT FDA REPORTS ON EPHEDRA
When
Taken According to Current Standards, Latest FDA Reports Consistent
with Previous Findings, No Association Between Ephedra Consumption
and Serious Adverse Events
Washington,
DC (June 5, 2001) �
Experts who reviewed the most recent Food and Drug Administration
(FDA) reports on Ephedra confirmed their conclusion, based
on the totality of evidence, that these reports do not demonstrate
an association between Ephedra consumption and serious adverse
events (AERs). This conclusion is consistent with recent clinical
data showing that Ephedra is safe and beneficial for weight
loss, and with the previous findings of Cantox Health Sciences
International's quantitative risk analysis, and of a multidisciplinary
expert panel sponsored by the Ephedra Education Council (EEC).
As
part of an ongoing effort to work with the FDA and other federal
and state agencies to establish responsible standards for
dietary supplements containing Ephedra, the dietary supplement
industry has obtained from FDA the most recent AERs for Ephedra
products. AERs cannot be viewed as scientific "data," and
it is not possible to use AERs to establish whether an event
is attributable to Ephedra or whether Ephedra increases the
risk of adverse events. Nonetheless, industry has agreed to
review all new AERs that FDA receives for Ephedra products
in an effort to help monitor whether the current national
standard for these products is working, and in order to foster
a more cooperative approach with FDA concerning the regulation
of these products.
"The
review of the most recent AERs is consistent with the written
comments of the Expert Panel of the Ephedra Education Council
submitted to FDA in October 2000, which stated that 'available
information does not demonstrate an association between the
use of dietary supplements containing ephedrine alkaloids
and serious adverse events' when consumed according to the
national standard," said Dr. Stephen Kimmel, Chairman of the
EEC's Expert Panel.
"These
conclusions are also consistent with a quantitative risk study
submitted to FDA in December 2000 by Cantox Health Sciences
International, and with data from clinical studies on ephedrine
and Ephedra products, including the recently published abstract
of the Harvard and Columbia study," Dr. Kimmel added.
Researchers
at the prestigious Harvard and Columbia Universities, who
recently published data in abstract form in the FASEB Journal
and Obesity Research, found that herbal Ephedra, when combined
with caffeine, lowered body weight, fat and body mass index.
There were no significant adverse events in this 6-month study,
and rigorous testing of cardiac function showed little or
no effect on heart rate or blood pressure. In addition, data
published last month in The International Journal of Obesity
also showed that the combination of Ephedra and Guarana in
healthy, overweight subjects produced significant weight and
fat loss.
As
with past reports, the most recent batch of AERs shows why
frequent media reporting of the raw number of AERs is meaningless
and only confuses consumers. The new AERs include many that
bear no relationship to Ephedra consumption. This includes
reports on products that did not contain Ephedra, reports
where no adverse event is listed, and cases where the event
occurred well prior to any Ephedra consumption. Also included
were cases medically unrelated to Ephedra, such as gallstones,
small bowel obstruction and fat feet, as well as ludicrous
reports such as that of a married woman who had an affair
with a student, for which she has been criminally prosecuted.
The only experts who have reviewed the entire FDA collection
of AERs have consistently found that the AERs, when considered
in the context of scientific data from clinical studies, do
not represent a public health concern when Ephedra products
are consumed according to current standards - a total dose
of 100mg per day at 25mg four times a day.
Most
important, the enormous potential benefits of Ephedra products
for millions of consumers must be considered. According to
the Centers for Disease Control, more than 60% of Americans
are obese or overweight, and obesity results in 300,000 preventable
deaths each year in the United States. Because of the clinical
data showing safety and efficacy, leading experts in obesity
have urged FDA to permit continued access to Ephedra products,
one of the few useful tools that consumers have to help them
lose weight.
The
Ephedra Education Council (EEC) is supported primarily by
members of the Ephedra Committee of the American Herbal Products
Association, a recognized leader in promoting the safe and
responsible marketing of dietary supplements. The Council
provides factual information to the media and public about
dietary supplements containing Ephedra. For more information,
logon to www.EphedraFacts.com.
###